New study finds patient privacy risks in sharing research data

By Sally Crocker

Liam O’Neill

 

In publishing new studies, health care researchers take care to remove identifiable patient information when sharing their data.

But a UNT Health Science Center public health professor has found that despite such precautionary measures, often required by grant-funding organizations and research journals, online attackers can still identify individual patient health records through cross-referencing against publicly available databases.

Liam O’Neill, PhD, Associate Professor of Health Management and Policy at the UNTHSC School of Public Health, published the report in the June 2016 issue of with colleagues from the University of Iowa and George Washington University.

The article was featured as the June cover story and was also highlighted in a recent . The journal’s editor-in-chief, Dr. Steven L. Shafer of Stanford University, said he believes the article “will have profound implications for digital sharing of patient data” in the future.

“Posting health information that has been properly ‘de-identified’ for public use is assumed to pose no risks to patient privacy, yet computer scientists have demonstrated that this assumption is flawed,” Dr. O’Neill said.

“Knowing a person’s date of birth is insufficient by itself, for example, to identify an individual,” he said, “yet, 87 percent of the specific combinations of date of birth, postal code and gender occur only once among the entire U.S. population.”

“The first step is for an online attacker to link two or more open databases based on overlapping attributes,” he said.

For their study, Dr. O’Neill and colleagues used the State of Texas surgical database – containing public information on more than 2.8 million records – to show that there is a 42.8 percent chance that an online attacker could match an anesthesia record to a de-identified hospital database to uncover sensitive patient information.

The percentage is even greater, they reported, for patients undergoing multiple procedures or from smaller states.

“Few people today would think that the combination of hospital and surgical procedures could be enough to link to a single inpatient record out of a database of millions,” Dr. O’Neill said, “which is why the use or exchange of this type of data is largely unregulated. But methods of online attack are advancing rapidly, faster than methods of defense.” Dr. O’Neill said.

While supporting research transparency, the authors recommended a change in peer-reviewed editorial policy, where study data could be requested from a journal’s editor, rather than being publicly shared in de-identified format.

Funding for this study was provided by the .

Recent News

1
  • Our People
|Sep 17, 2024

HSC College of scientists named in World’s Top 2% in latest edition from Stanford University/Elsevier

Stanford University and Elsevier have released the sixth edition of their World’s Top 2% of Scientists List, which features three faculty members from The University of North Texas Health Science Center at Fort Worth's College of . The rankings were based on data compiled through 2022, ...
May 29, 2020.
  • Community
|Sep 13, 2024

Important update on Willed Body Program

We have become aware of issues within our Willed Body Program, and that failures existed in its management and oversight. The program has fallen short of the standards of respect, care, and professionalism that we demand. The University of North Texas Health Science Center at Fort Worth extends its ...
Tammy Wheat
  • Patient Care
|Sep 12, 2024

New aquatic exercise program at ForeverFit offers hope, healing for cancer patients

The University of North Texas Health Science Center at Fort Worth’s ForeverFit clinic, a no-cost exercise space exclusively for cancer patients and survivors, now offers a free aquatic exercise program. The innovative program harnesses the benefits of hydrotherapy to provide a gentle, yet p...
Aaic
  • Research
|Sep 10, 2024

TCOM faculty member participates in the elite Butler-Williams Scholars Program hosted by NIA

After 10 years as a clinician, Lubnaa Abdullah, Psy.D, ABPP, was ready for a change. Her career as a clinical psychologist with specialty training in neuropsychology was rewarding, but she wanted something new and has found it at the Texas College of Osteopathic Medicine at The University of North T...